APA vs Toyoko Inn vs Super Hotel: Which Japanese Budget Chain to Book

If you are trying to decide between APA vs Toyoko Inn vs Super Hotel, the short version is this: choose Toyoko Inn if a free breakfast and a station-front address matter more than square footage, choose Super Hotel if you want a proper bath at the end of the day and don't mind a similarly small room, and choose APA if you need the widest choice of locations and are fine paying for breakfast separately. Rooms at APA Hotel Shinjuku Kabukicho Tower start from about ¥9,700 a night outside peak season (checked August 2026), and the other two chains sit in a similar band nearby. The answer flips if you're traveling as a pair and want a bath big enough to use in turn — that tips it toward Super Hotel, or Dormy Inn at a slightly higher rate.

Some links in this guide are affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

What APA, Toyoko Inn and Super Hotel actually differ on

APA, Toyoko Inn and Super Hotel sit in the same rough price bracket, but each picked a different feature to compete on. Toyoko Inn built its brand on breakfast being free at every property. APA built its scale on having a hotel within minutes of almost any major station. Super Hotel built its reputation on a bath worth using after a full day on your feet. None of that shows up on a price filter, so it's worth laying the three out side by side first.

Prices above are single-room rates for each chain's Shinjuku Kabukicho-area property, checked live in August 2026 — they move daily and by season, so treat them as a same-neighborhood comparison rather than a fixed rate.

Breakfast is where the three chains split

Breakfast is the biggest line-item difference between the three chains, and it's also where we have the most firsthand material. APA charges for breakfast at nearly every property — a buffet running roughly ¥1,500 to ¥3,850 depending on the hotel, priced lower booked in advance (confirmed at several APA properties, checked August 2026). Toyoko Inn includes breakfast free at every property; Super Hotel includes it at most, with a handful of locations charging separately — and the format isn't identical between the two chains, or always identical hotel to hotel within one chain.

We stayed at APA Hotel Nagoya-Ekimae in October 2024 and paid for the buffet: a tray-set meal built around two fried shrimp in a red miso sauce, plus grilled salmon, sausage, simmered beef, a rolled omelet, salad and miso soup — a distinctly Nagoya-flavored spread rather than a generic hotel breakfast.

We stayed at Toyoko Inn Fukui-Ekimae, where the free breakfast was handed out as a takeaway box: rice with furikake, a rolled omelet, simmered hijiki, simmered beans, miso soup and tea. That's what we were served on our stay — other guest reviews describe a full buffet on different visits, and Toyoko Inn's breakfast arrangements vary by property and have changed over time, so confirm the current setup with the hotel before you book. Take "free breakfast" as confirmed chain-wide; the exact format is what to check.

Super Hotel's breakfast leans toward a health-food buffet where it's included — fresh-baked bread and organic salad are recurring elements, served roughly 7:00 to 9:00 AM — though a handful of properties charge for it separately rather than folding it into the room rate.

Room size and the APA trade-off

APA's standard single at the Shinjuku Kabukicho Tower runs about 11 m² with a 122 cm-wide bed, smaller than either Toyoko Inn's or Super Hotel's usual single, both close to 12 m² at the properties we checked — the Toyoko Inn single we photographed at Fukui-Ekimae is that same ~12 m² size. Larger APA room types exist — some run 14 to 15 m² with wider or twin-bed configurations — but they cost more and aren't the default room type on most APA listings. The trade-off: APA's larger network puts a smaller room within reach of more exact locations, a few minutes from a shinkansen exit or conference center, where a slightly bigger Toyoko Inn or Super Hotel room might sit two stations further out.

Where each chain has the most locations

APA is the largest of the three by a wide margin. The company's own figures put it at 1,041 hotels and 141,457 rooms as of January 9, 2026, a total that includes properties still under construction and independently run APA Direct-affiliated hotels, not only fully open properties. Toyoko Inn is second at 361 hotels as of February 7, 2026 — a count that made it, per the company, the first Japanese chain to open in all 47 prefectures plus five countries overseas. Super Hotel is smallest but still substantial: 178 hotels in Japan plus two overseas (Myanmar, Vietnam), for 180 total, per a company press release dated April 22, 2026.

Add the three companies' own published totals and you get more than 1,580 hotels (checked August 2026) — though the scopes differ: APA's figure folds in overseas and under-construction properties, Toyoko Inn's spans all 47 prefectures plus five countries, and Super Hotel's 178 is Japan-only. Even so, it's more combined coverage than almost any single alternative chain offers a traveler moving between cities on one trip.

For a wider set of chains beyond these three, our guide to Japan's best hotel chains covers the full field, and our Osaka budget hotels and Shinjuku budget hotels guides break down specific properties by neighborhood rather than by brand.

Loyalty programs a short-trip visitor can actually use

None of the three loyalty programs charge an annual fee, but they pay off on different timelines. Toyoko Inn Club Card matters fastest: a one-time ¥1,500 admin fee (¥1,000 for students) buys a 5% discount on official-site or app bookings starting immediately, plus a free night per 10 paid stays — worth joining for a single stay if the room costs more than the sign-up fee. Super Hotel's Smart Membership is free to join and earns 500 points a night from your first stay, more at Silver and Gold (10 or 20 nights a year); points redeem in 1,000-point blocks for cash back and expire after about a year, so they suit a multi-night trip better than one night. APA's status system runs five tiers, Regular to President, on annual nights and spend; a first-timer starts at Regular with baseline point accrual only, while the better perks — extended stay hours, priority booking — go to guests who return within the same year.

Which to book by trip type

If included breakfast matters most, book Toyoko Inn. If you want a bath to end the day and don't mind a small room, book Super Hotel — check the hotel name for "natural hot spring" if a real onsen matters to you, since some locations use an artificial carbonated bath instead, as Super Hotel Shinjuku Kabukicho does. If your priority is finding a hotel exactly where you need one, in a city Toyoko Inn or Super Hotel might not reach, book APA and budget for breakfast separately.

FAQ: APA vs Toyoko Inn vs Super Hotel

Is APA Hotel better than Toyoko Inn for a solo traveler?

For a single night in a city center, APA's larger network usually wins on location, but its standard rooms run smaller (about 11 m² at the Shinjuku Kabukicho Tower) and breakfast costs extra. Toyoko Inn's rooms run a little larger and include breakfast, so the total cost often ends up similar once you add a meal to the APA stay. Pick APA when the exact location matters most, Toyoko Inn when included breakfast and a bit more room matter more.

Which is cheaper, Toyoko Inn or Super Hotel?

At the Shinjuku Kabukicho properties we checked in August 2026, Super Hotel was cheaper (from ¥7,250) than Toyoko Inn (from ¥10,362) for a single room on the same night. That gap isn't guaranteed everywhere — rates move with demand, day of week and location — but Super Hotel tends to undercut Toyoko Inn in cities where both chains compete head to head.

Does Super Hotel have free breakfast like Toyoko Inn?

Mostly. Toyoko Inn includes breakfast free at every property, while Super Hotel includes it at most properties, with a handful of locations charging separately. Toyoko Inn's format ranges from a full buffet to a takeaway box, and Super Hotel leans toward a health-food buffet with fresh-baked bread and organic salad where it's included. Either way, both build breakfast into far more stays than APA, which charges for it at nearly all of its hotels.

Is APA Hotel's breakfast included in the room rate?

No. APA charges separately for breakfast at nearly all of its properties, typically ¥1,500 to ¥3,850 for a buffet depending on the hotel and whether you book it in advance or on the day. A handful of APA rate plans bundle breakfast in, so check the specific plan description before assuming it's included.